"Des waerelds doen en doolen, is maar een mallemoolen,"

"Des waerelds doen en doolen, is maar een mallemoolen," engraving from Het Groote Tafereel der Dwaasheid, 1720.

"The actions and designs of the world go round as if in a mill." South Sea bubble financial crisis.

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

The economic and social importance of the LIBOR














The allegation of LIBOR manipulation by some banks offers one the opportunity to ponder on the importance of that single number. Donald MacKenzie gave the following figures in 2008:
Judged by the amount of money directly dependent on it, the British Bankers’ Association’s London Interbank Offered Rate matters more than any other set of numbers in the world. LIBOR anchors contracts totalling around $300 trillion, the equivalent of $45,000 for every human being on the planet [...] For instance, the level of LIBOR determines the monthly payments on around half of the adjustable-rate mortgages in the US: rates are set as LIBOR plus a fixed margin and reset periodically at LIBOR changes [...]  LIBOR is even more central to the huge market for interest-rate swaps.
The process of its calculation rest on a conditional question asked to banks however. That is, at which rate each bank "could borrow funds, were it to do so by asking for and then accepting inter-bank offers in reasonable market size just prior to 11.00. " (11.00 being the time each bank has to submit their rate). The flaw in this process is obviously the jugdement of what a bank could do, instead of what it has done. But the risk of manipulation is thought to be mitigated by the fact that that manipulation would have to take place in the public arena, since the inputs of the LIBOR are highly scrutinized. So a banks lowering artificially its rate while others wouldn't would be spotted easily and risk exclusion from the panel.

So in order to manipulate the rate to profit from the derivatives contract connected to it, for example, banks must cooperate.

And they seem to have just done that. 

Sunday, March 25, 2012

The Wall Street exception















Here's an interview with Gretchen Morgenson on the different set of rules Wall Street seems to enjoy compared to the rest of society. Seeing it as formal (law, regulation) and informal constraints (norms, tradition, worldviews), in the tradition of Institutional Economics can be valuable. What kind of informal constraints have been changed in the financial sector (and within the corresponding regulatory agencies) so that a change in formal constraints have taken place ? The interview with Morgenson reveals a shift from what is considered serious criminal offence for the rest of society - fraud - to some sort of minor mistake. As the the interviewer Chris Martenson puts it, it is change of both the "perception and the application of the rule of law".

Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Innovative SMEs

Infographic explanation, courtesy of GOODS.is
 
















The OECD report on which it is based here. So we know SMEs are important for economic development, competitiveness and innovation. Who will finance them ?

Monday, January 2, 2012

Watching for Polanyi's double movement

Reuters / Stephen Hird

Political Economist Karl Polanyi argued that the rise of the capitalist economy implied another social order and that whenever markets attempted to free themselves from their social moorings, one could expect the "natural" (and violent) return of society. Michael Thomas thinks its coming soon:
As 2011 slithers to its end, none of the major problems that led to the crisis point three years ago have really been solved. Bank balance sheets still reek. Europe day by day becomes a financial black hole, with matter from the periphery being sucked toward the center until the vortex itself collapses. The Street and its ministries of propaganda have fallen back on a Big Lie as old as capitalism itself: that all that has gone wrong has been government’s fault. This time, however, I don’t think the argument that “Washington ate my homework” is going to work. This time, a firestorm is going to explode about the Street’s head—and about time, too.

Saturday, December 31, 2011

Middle class, SMEs and Democracy


















Sergey Guriev and Aleh Tsyvinski bundle them alogether to argue the ineluctable democratization of Russia: 
In short, the third main lesson of Russia’s transition is that state capitalism does not work (at least not without a strong meritocratic political party, as in China). Indeed, recent events have shown the system to be inherently unstable. As market reforms have brought substantial prosperity (average annual per capita GDP, at purchasing power parity, is now $17,000), a large middle class, based mostly in small and medium-size companies and the service sector, developed beyond the reach of the state-owned behemoths. Most of this middle class also lives in large cities – where the battle for Russia’s future is now taking place.
Hence the crucial importance of knowing more about how Russian SMEs are financed. Family  and friends are not sufficient, big Russian banks tend not to lend to SMEs. Foreign banks are supporting international commerce, small local bank are very inneficient. The lending technologies available in Russia are not manyfold, because their use depends on the institutional structure (courts, credit bureau) in place. It also depends on social relation. It has been proven that social relations help to reduce interest rate on loan, which is an advantage of relationship lending. However, little is known on how the social context structures creditors - lenders relationships in transition countries.

Thursday, December 29, 2011

The financial transmission belt















Supposed to allocate capital is clearly broken. From the FT: 
The amounts of cash being deposited by eurozone banks at the European Central Bank increased further on Wednesday, just days after the ECB provided unprecedented levels of liquidity in an effort to reduce tension in the financial system.
 Happy 2012. 

Thursday, December 22, 2011

Weberian thoughts on Orthodoxy and economic development

The Economist reviews the sacrosanct Weberian argument of the influence of religion on economic behavior. To cut a long story short (and this one is centuries old) the relationship is not direct. Linking prosperous economies with faith runs up against exceptions. The Greek example illustrates the issue rather nicely: 
Similarly, contemplating Greece’s economic woes, it is easy to dream up some theory that connects Orthodox Christianity (and its comparatively charitable attitude to human weakness) with corruption or cronyism. Orthodoxy has a less pessimistic view of “original sin” than the Christian West—and its prayers for the dead emphasise “no man lives who does not sin”. Does that imply winking at misdeeds? Possibly—but then try explaining why Greek-Americans, who are at least as devout as their motherland kin, do so very well in business, education and public service. The plausible reason lies in America’s institutions which make it easier to prosper in an honest way.
But institutions is not only formal rules. Institutions seen as encompassing worldviews and habit can then in turn be greatly influenced by religion. The Russian case offers a telling example. Its disrespect for the rule of law - and the economic consequences it implies - can be traced back to Orthodoxy. Newcity M. in "The rule of law and economic reform in Russia, edited by Sachs and Pistor" writes: 
Russia never developed a legalistic tradition. The reason for this is that is was Christianized by Byzantium instead of Rome. Western Europe did not receive Roman legal culture directly. It was transmitted and refracted primarily through the Roman Church, which fostered a legalistic, rather than mystical, world view drawn from Roman culture. This contrasts sharply with the world view fostered by the Russian Orthodox Church. The [Roman] Church was intent on establishing a universal body of ecclesiastical legal principles that would bind Western Christendom together regardless of secular divisions. The origins of the Western notion of law as an autonomous body of principles to which secular authorities are subject can be traced to this period. The Orthodox church, however, rejected the independence and supremacy of the papacy and remained an integral part od the state. In this way, Russia missed the most important foundations of the Western concept of the rule of law.
If faith can influence indirectly economic behavior. The way a religion is institutionalized (and its relationship with secular power) can have deep long-lasting influences on economic development.